Exposing Lies Told by At-Fault Drivers in New Jersey

There is an obvious incentive for at-fault drivers to lie after causing accidents in New Jersey. These lies can obscure the true causes of accidents, potentially making it more difficult for victims to pursue sufficient compensation for serious injuries. Meanwhile, at-fault drivers may avoid the consequences of their actions, including higher insurance premiums or even criminal charges. So, how do you expose these lies after a serious car accident? How do you prove that the other driver is not telling the truth about what really happened? A recent incident in New Jersey shows that these lies aren’t always successful.

Two Women Accused of Lying to Police After Fatal Car Crash in New Jersey

In April of 2025, NJ.com reported that two women had been accused of lying to law enforcement officials after their involvement in a fatal car crash. The collision claimed the life of a motorcyclist in Jersey City. After striking the motorcyclist at an intersection, the female driver quickly called her mother. This older woman then arrived at the scene and claimed to be the one who was driving the vehicle at the time of the collision.

What was the reason for this elaborate switcheroo? Simple: The younger woman was driving on a suspended license. She called her mother because she knew she would face serious criminal charges if she were caught behind the wheel.

However, this fraud did not stand up to scrutiny for very long. Police asked the older woman why she was absent immediately after the collision, and the mother replied that she had to drop her grandson off at school. She claimed that after she had dropped the child off, she returned to the scene. Police were obviously skeptical about this account, and the woman soon caved in and admitted she was driving in a different vehicle when the accident occurred.

Now, both the driver and her mother are facing criminal charges in connection with this fatal accident. The mother faces charges of obstruction and hindering, while the driver is being charged with the same offense, plus false reporting and causing death while driving on a suspended license. Police say that her license has been suspended for almost 30 years.

Witnesses proved to be a key aspect of this investigation. Fortunately, someone saw the driver climb out of the passenger window of her car, and she noted that there were no other passengers inside the vehicle. However, the bizarre nature of the mother’s story probably made this lie easy to spot as well. No one in their right mind would leave the scene of a car crash to drop a child off at school, especially after striking and killing a motorcyclist. Even if this actually occurred, as the mother claimed, it would still constitute a hit-and-run.

How Can I Expose Lies After a Car Crash in New Jersey?

You can rely on police officers and detectives to expose the most obvious lies. These law enforcement professionals know how to spot a lie, and they are familiar with the various strategies defendants use when attempting to avoid consequences.

If police seem to believe the defendant and you know that they are lying, you may rely on other forms of evidence to prove your case. You might review surveillance footage from nearby cameras. You can also track down eyewitnesses who might have seen the crash and ask them to provide statements.

This process of evidence-gathering is much easier with help from an experienced personal injury attorney. Your lawyer can pursue important documents, records, and evidence from law enforcement or the defendant in an effort to expose their lies. Due to the legal process of “discovery,” relevant parties may have no other choice but to hand over this evidence.

If all else fails, your lawyer can cross-examine the other driver after calling them to the witness stand. The defendant will be asked to testify under oath, and any lies they tell will constitute a criminal offense called “contempt of court.”

Can a New Jersey Auto Accident Lawyer Help Me Prove Fault?

If you’re recovering from an accident and you believe that the other driver is lying about what happened, be sure to speak with an experienced personal injury attorney in New Jersey. These legal professionals can look into your accident in more detail, exposing potential lies and omissions from the other driver. In order to achieve this goal, they may rely on video footage, eyewitness accounts, cellphone records, and much more. Learn more about the next potential steps by contacting Lependorf & Silverstein today.